The 209 schools that made our 2023 rankings for The Best Value Colleges all share three exceptional features:

  • stellar academics
  • affordable cost—either via a comparatively low sticker price or generous financial aid (or both!)
  • strong career prospects for graduates

Students who attend these schools don't have to mortgage their futures to pay for their degrees—and we believe they will graduate with great career prospects.

We chose our Best Value Colleges for 2023 based on data we collected from fall 2022 through spring 2023 via our institutional and student surveys and from PayScale.com on alumni career and salary statistics. Broadly speaking, we weighted more than 40 data points covering academics, costs, financial aid, debt, grad rates, and career/salary data. 

Return-on-Investment (ROI) Rating

Our ROI rating for each school includes PayScale.com data collected through April 2022 from alumni surveys covering starting and mid-career salaries, and career social impact.

Our ROI rating also draws on the following information we’ve collected and analyzed:

Academic Rating

To tally this rating, we analyze data the schools report to us about their academic selectivity and admissions, plus opinion data we collect from students reporting on the education they are receiving at their schools. The admissions statistics shed light on how difficult it is to gain acceptance: they include average SAT/ACT scores and high school GPA of enrolled first-years as well as other data points. The student data reveals how students at the school rate their professors' teaching skills as well as how accessible the professors are outside of class.

Financial Aid Rating

This rating is based on a combination of school-reported data and student opinion. Schools report the amount of need-based aid they give students. Students report how happy they are with their award packages. Very few students, it seems, are ever totally elated about their financial aid packages and the services (or lack thereof) that offices of financial aid provide. Nevertheless, students at some schools are a lot happier than students at other schools.

College Costs

We start with the sticker price of each college (often referred to as "cost of attendance," which includes tuition, required fees, and room and board), and subtract the average gift aid (scholarships and grants) awarded to students. We don't subtract work-study or student loans because those are costs that students ultimately have to bear. Next, we take all of this data and stir it up in an algorithm that measures the best bang for your buck: excellent academics, great financial aid, and/or low cost of attendance. Simply put, it means value.

Click to read additional details about our college ratings.

Click to read the methodology for the 15 ranking lists associated with Best Value.

Out of the more than 650 schools we considered on this project, the 209 we chose as our 2022 Best Value Colleges are, in our opinion truly the most exceptional in the nation at delivering great academics, affordable cost, and great career foundations. We strongly recommend and salute the colleges we present here for all that they do to help their students with need afford to attend them while delivering an amazing college experience that's worth every penny.